Skip to content

MHAMD Perspectives

Class Action Lawsuit Filed in California Alleging Violation of State Parity Law

Press Release of the Los Angeles Law Firm of Cohen Mckeon, May 21, 2012

A class-action lawsuit was filed against United Healthcare Insurance Company, US Behavioral Plan, and California United Behavioral Health, which contracts with employers such as the University of California to provide mental health services to policyholders.

The class-action suit alleges that these companies, which are part of United Healthcare Insurance Company, have violated the California Mental Health Parity Act, which requires insurers to provide treatment for mental-health diagnoses according to “the same terms and conditions” applied to medical conditions. Specifically, the defendants are accused of denying and improperly limiting coverage by conducting concurrent and prospective reviews of routine outpatient mental health treatments when no such reviews are conducted for routine outpatient treatments for other medical conditions. Defendants are also accused of violating the Unruh Act, by discriminating against a class of persons with mental disabilities and psychiatric conditions; violating California’s law prohibiting unfair competition, breaching the terms of its own insurance contract with policyholders, and the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing.

The law suit was filed in Santa Barbara Superior Court on behalf of the plaintiff, who works in Santa Barbara. Her mental health coverage was improperly reduced. She was having four weekly outpatient psychotherapy sessions, but in September, 2011 she was informed that she would limited to one weekly session for one month. Plaintiff is represented by the Los Angeles-based class-action trial lawyers of Cohen McKeon LLP, and Meiram Bendat, founder of the mental health insurance-advocacy service, Psych-Appeal.

“This is an important case because it addresses an issue that impacts a wide range of people who are covered by health insurance” said lead attorney, Michael L. Cohen. “For too long, people who suffer from severe mental health issues have not received health insurance coverage on the same terms as conditions that are applied to other conditions.”

 

Related News

Class Action Suit Filed Against United Healthcare Alleging Parity Violation

Tags: All Categories, Uncategorized

Pomerantz Law Firm Has Filed a Class Action Against UnitedHealth Group, Inc. for Violations of Federal and State Mental Health Parity Laws – UNH March 12, 2013 15:20 | Source: Pomerantz Grossman Hufford Dahlstrom & Gross LLP NEW YORK, March 12, 2013 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — Pomerantz Grossman Hufford Dahlstrom & Gross LLP has filed a …

Read more

California Regulators Cite Kaiser Permanente for Violating Parity Laws

Tags: All Categories, Uncategorized

As written about by John Grohol in Psych Central, Kaiser Permanente, California’s largest HMO was found by the California Department of Managed Health Care to be violating patient protection laws. California requires that patients wait no more than 10 days for an appointment to see a specialist. Kaiser Permanente was found to keep some patients …

Read more

Insurer in CA Faces Steep Fines for Violation of State Parity Law

Tags: All Categories, Uncategorized

The HMO, Kaiser Permanente was recently fined $4m by the State of California for violating California mental health parity law. The fine, the second largest in California history, was in response to Kaiser’s failure to provide access to mental health care in a timely manner. Along with the fine, California Department of Insurance issued a …

Read more

Help MHAMD Now.

Every Donation Makes a Difference.

Your gift will help us protect mental health and ensure equitable access to care for all Marylanders.